Wigley: Referendum Caution

Dafydd Wigley is urging caution on a rush into a referendum on full law-making powers for the Welsh assembly.

Writing in his Daily Post Welsh-language blog, the Plaid grandee recalls the devolution referendum of 1979:

In Wales, there was an overwhelming 'No' vote. It was caused partly because of confusion emanating from three years of parliamentary arguments; partly because Labour was split down the centre; partly because it presented a chance to teach an unpopular government a lesson; and partly because of a lack of confidence amongst the Welsh people...

Today Labour MPs are split on the question of giving full law-making powers to the National Assembly. The split amongst Labour ranks is extremely similar to that which existed in 1979. Also today, as in 1979, we observe a tired Labour government which is fast losing people's confidence.

Without learning the lessons of history, we are certain to repeat the same mistakes. It would be very helpful if those who call today for a quick referendum, consider for a moment the lessons which date from the 70s. As a nation we must never again repeat the same tragic mistakes we saw at that time, and the fiasco of a referendum that took place 30 years ago this week.

It was impossible to avoid the enthusiasm of proponents of further devolution following last week's BBC/ICM polls showing more than 50% backing greater powers for the assembly. Some began talking openly about the need for a referendum as soon as possible, without necessarily waiting for the All Wales Convention to report its own findings before getting a full Yes campaign up and running.

But Dafydd Wigley, the wise old sage of the party, holds great strength over every tier of Plaid. His air of caution must surely be a response to these calls for a rapid referendum, and his own experiences of 1979 and 1997 are undoubtedly fuelling his demands for Plaid members to ease off the referendum accelerator.

Though amongst Wigley's cautious foreboding, he does suggest that Wales would be foolish not to vote for full law-making powers before the next Westminster general election:

When there is a Conservative government in Westminster again, imposing policies which are acceptable to south east England but which are repellent to Wales, the message will begin hitting home. By then the Scottish Parliament will be able to lead its own agenda, in line with the wishes of the Scottish people. Wales will have to follow the priorities of south east England which will be imposed on it from Westminster.